Sweet Theory Baking Co.

05JUL25 we got a cinnamon streusel coffee cake n a lemon poppy strawberry jam cupcake that cinnamon streusel had that nice blend of cinnamon n sugar. after i ate some in the car i wish i had some coffee w it bc oh man, that would've hit. i recommend eating half now n the other half later, that way you have some later n the lemon poppy strawberry jam cupcake was the perfect size, we ate it otw to our next destination. bro that lemon flavor was exactly what we wanted, not overpowering, just rig

I am from Kansas visiting Jacksonville Fl, this past weekend for my birthday. My daughters and I stayed in Jacksonville, but my purpose was to go St Augustine. But my daughter who lives in Florida has a health diagnosis that makes her have to eat free of certain ingredients. She told me about the Sweet Theory Baking Co and how delicious it is and free of alot of ingredients that I agree with 😊. She also said that you have to get there early enough because the line gets lonngggg, and the store m

Super cute bakery with one of the best selection of vegan treats I've seen. My friend got the doughnuts (plural), which were excellent, and I tried the BLT biscuit and pineapple loaf. The consistency of the bread was perfect, and the biscuits rivaled the best I've had in Nashville. The place is cozy, where standing in line 2 strangers and I found ourselves in conversation about which to choose, even though one person had been coming here for fifteen years. And the old Bundt cake tins brought bac

AMAZING!!! Super fluffy bar cakes and muffins with the perfect texture. Very nice and helpful staff, Ethan and Ben explained to menu to help me figure out exactly what I wanted. Iced coffee was delicious too. Will be back for sure

Can't believe these are gluten, dairy, egg and nut free!! My daughter has a ton of food allergies so finding this shop was a huge blessing for her birthday today. Definitely need to go back The maple pumpkin loaf was delicious as well as the pumpkin vanilla cupcake