Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard

We recently visited Rita's for the first time and got the pina colada and mango gelati with vanilla custard. We enjoyed the treats but thought they were slightly overpriced. If you are lactose intolerant definitely avoid the custard...it wrecked me. Also, there's no place to sit so take your treats to go. Otherwise, nice staff and good options!

Great quality ice cream and custard always. My favourite was the cheesecake flavoured custard topped with vanilla waffers. Also the owners of this store are a very sweet couple. Definitely visiting here again.

*Response received inviting me to call, best if you folks reply to the letter via email given, thank you* Deep dive because I care about this brand. I have enjoyed the product at this Rita's many times, but my August 2025 visit was frustrating enough that I decided to pause visits until improvements are made. The frozen custard can be excellent. The operation and owner engagement fell short in avoidable ways. what happened during my visit • Disorganized payment flow: I was handed my sundae be

Excellent customer service and great ice cream but charging 8$ for a cone is a joke!

I've been getting Rita's since I was a kid and I loved it then and I still love it. It's always a great sweet treat and it was again today. The owners and staff are really polite and were very welcoming. I have tried almost all of their different drink options, but the Italian Ice is still my favorite and their best seller. Today I chose a large cherry with salted caramel custard on top and it was absolutely fantastic. I don't think I would ever not be in the mood for it. The only downside is wh